Despite initial skepticism, Judge James Donato has surprised many by considering Epic Games’ demands in the trial against Google. The demands include allowing the Epic Games Store to exist within Google Play Store and providing access to every app inside Google Play.
Judge Donato has ordered Google to calculate the costs of complying with these demands by June 24th. This involves providing details on the tech work required and any economic costs associated with granting “Catalog Access” and “Library Porting” to competing app stores for up to six years.
The document, MDL Dkt. No. 952, outlines Epic’s 16-page list of demands, with page 7 specifically calling for Google to give other app stores access to the entire Google Play catalog of apps. This is a significant request that could have far-reaching implications for the app store market.
In the upcoming final hearing on August 14th, Epic will have the opportunity to question Google’s experts and engineers about the accuracy of their estimates. Judge Donato has expressed skepticism towards Google’s arguments against Epic’s proposed remedies but also raised concerns about the vagueness of some of Epic’s demands.
The outcome of the trial between Epic Games and Google could have a significant impact on the app store ecosystem. If Judge Donato rules in favor of Epic’s demands, it could pave the way for greater competition and innovation in the app store market. However, it remains to be seen how Google will respond to these demands and what the final decision of the court will be.
The Epic Games vs. Google trial has raised important questions about the power dynamics within the app store industry. Judge Donato’s consideration of Epic’s demands underscores the potential for change in how app stores operate and compete. As the trial continues to unfold, it will be crucial to monitor the developments and potential implications for both Epic Games and Google.
Leave a Reply