Starboard Value, an activist fund managed by Jeff Smith, has acquired a substantial stake in the graphics-design firm Autodesk. The fund has engaged in discussions with the company’s board regarding several serious concerns related to its disclosures surrounding an internal investigation that led to the removal of its chief financial officer. Sources familiar with the matter have estimated Starboard’s stake in Autodesk to be around $500 million. The fund, known for its investment activities in the technology sector, is particularly troubled by the timing of Autodesk’s disclosure of the internal investigation findings. These findings revealed that company executives had misled investors about the company’s free cash flow metrics and operating margins. The investigation uncovered that executives had manipulated reporting related to the company’s contract billing structure as Autodesk transitioned back to upfront payments from annualized payments in order to enhance these metrics.
Notably, the probe resulted in the removal of Autodesk’s then-CFO, Deborah Clifford, who was reassigned to a different executive role within the company. The delayed disclosure of the investigation’s findings raised concerns and left investors unsettled, causing Autodesk’s stock to plummet by 20% in the subsequent weeks. With the company’s market cap now hovering just below $50 billion, questions have arisen regarding the motive behind the delayed disclosure, coming shortly after the deadline for director nominations had passed. This sequence of events has prompted Starboard to contemplate legal action in the Delaware Chancery court. The fund is considering taking measures to force a reopening of Autodesk’s nominating window and a postponement of the company’s upcoming annual meeting, scheduled for July 16.
Starboard’s Proposed Strategies
In addition to addressing the disclosure issues and potential legal action, Starboard believes that Autodesk has the potential to enhance its actual margins and enhance investor communications, ultimately boosting the company’s stock performance. Starboard’s track record includes investments in other prominent technology companies such as Salesforce and Splunk, indicating its expertise in driving strategic changes and maximizing shareholder value. The fund’s intentions and plans were first reported by the Wall Street Journal, shedding light on Starboard’s proactive stance in addressing corporate governance and performance issues.
Autodesk’s encounter with activist scrutiny is not unprecedented, as the company previously reached settlements with activist investors from Sachem Head Capital Management and Eminence Capital in 2016 to avert a proxy battle. Furthermore, this year, Autodesk revealed that it is under investigation by both the Justice Department and the SEC, adding another layer of regulatory scrutiny to the company’s challenges. The combination of activist pressure and regulatory investigations underscores the complex landscape in which Autodesk operates and the imperative for the company to navigate these challenges effectively.
Starboard Value’s intervention in Autodesk highlights the crucial role that activist investors play in holding companies accountable for their actions and governance practices. By urging transparency, accountability, and improved performance, activist funds like Starboard can drive positive change within companies and enhance shareholder value. Autodesk now faces a critical juncture in addressing the fallout from the internal investigation and responding to the demands of its shareholders and stakeholders. Only time will tell how the company navigates these challenges and charts a path towards sustainable growth and success.
Leave a Reply